Star rating: 5/10
Genre: Steampunk-action
Run time: 128 minutes
Studio: Universal Pictures
Director: Christian Rivers
Cast: Hera Hilmar, Robert Sheehan, Huga Weaving, Jihae
Review:
Hey there,
I went to watch this movie with my family because my Dad was excited to see the cool machines that the filmmakers could come up with. While I found that part to be the saving grace of this film, even my Dad felt bored midway through the movie. “Quite predictable, no punch, but at least there were cool-ish machines,” was his summary of the film. My brother was more generous, stating that while it was nothing amazing, it wasn’t bad either. I am inclined to agree with them both.
This may actually be a controversial opinion but I found the movie fun. It was action-packed and the story was easy to follow. There was nothing too complicated for my mind to wrap around so I could just enjoy the movie for the sheer fun of it. The visuals were amazing and brought so many crazy ideas to life. I loved seeing what machines they could come up with, like the city in the sky. I also loved the idea of travelling cities and liked how the cities resembled our own with some cool tweaks.
However, the simple movie plot was probably why critics felt the need to leave unfavourable reviews. Another possible issue was the instantaneous romance between our 2 main characters. The chemistry between them was palpable but was not enough to make up for the flimsy story-telling. The romance build-up could have been lost in the adaptation from book to screen. I also found the ending cheesy but that’s a personal preference. Another problem, which could have been due to the adaptation process, is that of the backstory. There just isn’t much of it in the film. I don’t think I know why they decided to build moving cities after 2 hours of the movie. (This might be just me though, because my Dad and brother had to tell me how a major plot point was explained in an early scene in the film while referencing a backstory for the world of Mortal Engines. So if you are planning to watch this film, hopefully you won’t go in so blur*. If not, you may come out thinking the filmmakers missed something when in fact it was you… HAHA!)
One plot point I found incomprehensible was how Shan Guo reacted at the end of the film. (Refer to my P.S. at the end of this post for more spoiler-y info) Ultimately, this universe is full of idiots. For instance, I was completely disgusted at the beginning when the Londoners were cheering on the chase. It was sickening to watch the powerful bully the weak. Granted, after they caught the village, they took them in and cared for them. However, they clearly enjoyed the thrill of the chase. They chose to approach with force rather than make peace, and that is something that made my stomach turn. This was just my personal opinion and is possibly part of the film’s vague attempt of commentary on society in real life. Whichever it was, the rest of the film was great fun.
Overall, while my review seems filled with criticisms, it is genuinely a fun movie. I just wouldn’t be compelled to re-watch it. Let me know what you think, if you even watched the movie that is… *awkward laughter*… 😀
Thanks for reading
❤
*blur — Singlish term for being dense or slow
Other random thoughts: Did the poster remind anyone of another famous movie poster?
Another random thought: I thought that Robert Sheehan was Ben Whishaw at first. Now looking at the images online, I was far off. But does Sheehan look like half of Whishaw and half Eddie Redmayne? Is it just me?
Alternative view: I enjoy watching videos from this YouTube channel Let Me Explain and in this video he explains why he thinks The Mortal Engines flopped so badly at the box office.
P.S. SPOILERS AHEAD PROCEED WITH CAUTION
In Chinese, Shan Guo is 山国 which literally translates to ‘mountain country’ or ‘country of mountains’. That is my first language tidbit for everyone. Tidbit two is that the pronunciation used in the film is different from the Chinese one. Specifically, the [sha] in Shan was strangely pronounced like the [sha] like in “share” instead of the [shu] in “shut”, the latter which would be the correct Chinese pronunciation. The Guo as well is pronounced as [guh-woah] instead of [guh-w-aw]. But I suppose they were trying not to be too obvious that Shan Guo is China, or maybe I’m just completely wrong about this Chinese thing. Anyway, that is besides the point.
Shan Guo had destroyed cities in the past as seen from the carcasses outside The Great Wall when London was approaching with their nuclear weapon. They were also ready to annihilate London and everyone on it when they were being threatened.
However, after their precious wall, numerous homes and even lives had been destroyed by the invaders, the emperor still welcomed the Londoners into the walled city. If they would do that, why didn’t they just offer the same to other travelling cities? I’m not sure if I understand.